Most fix-and-flip investors calculate ROI wrong — and the mistake costs them more than they realize.
Here's the problem: the standard ROI formula (profit ÷ investment) doesn't account for time. A 20% return in 4 months is dramatically different from 20% in 12 months. And if you're not comparing deals on an annualized basis, you're making decisions with incomplete information.
Let's fix that.
The Basic ROI Formula
The simplest version:
ROI = (Net Profit ÷ Total Cash Invested) × 100
Sounds straightforward, but "total cash invested" is where most people get it wrong.
What to Include in Total Cash Invested
Your total cash invested is NOT just your down payment. It includes:
| Cost Category | Example |
|---|---|
| Down payment | $25,000 |
| Closing costs (buy side) | $3,500 |
| Points/origination fees | $5,625 |
| Rehab costs (cash fronted before draws) | $15,000 |
| Holding costs | $12,200 |
| Selling costs (agent, title, transfer tax) | $21,600 |
| Total Cash Invested | $82,925 |
Notice: even though you have a loan covering most of the purchase and rehab, your actual out-of-pocket includes all the costs listed above.
The ROI Calculation
Using the example above:
- ARV (Sale Price): $270,000
- Loan Payoff: $200,000
- Remaining Proceeds: $70,000
- Minus Selling Costs: $21,600
- Net Proceeds: $48,400
- Minus Total Cash Invested (excluding selling costs already counted): $61,325
- Net Profit: $48,400 - $61,325 = -$12,925...
Wait — that doesn't look right. Let's recalculate properly.
This is exactly the kind of mistake that happens with napkin math. Let's use a cleaner framework:
Total Project Cost = Purchase + Rehab + Holding + Buying Costs + Selling Costs = $180,000 + $45,000 + $12,200 + $9,125 + $21,600 = $267,925
Net Profit = ARV - Total Project Cost = $270,000 - $267,925 = $2,075
Total Cash Invested = Down Payment + Points + Cash Fronted for Rehab + Holding = $25,000 + $5,625 + $15,000 + $12,200 = $57,825
ROI = $2,075 ÷ $57,825 = 3.6%
That's... not great. And this is a deal that looked good on the surface.
Why Annualized ROI Matters
Now here's where it gets interesting. Let's compare two deals:
| Metric | Deal A | Deal B |
|---|---|---|
| Net Profit | $15,000 | $25,000 |
| Cash Invested | $50,000 | $80,000 |
| ROI | 30% | 31.25% |
| Hold Time | 4 months | 10 months |
| Annualized ROI | 90% | 37.5% |
Deal B has a higher raw ROI, but Deal A is far more efficient because your capital is recycled faster. Over 12 months, you could do three Deal A's but barely one Deal B.
Annualized ROI = ROI × (12 ÷ Hold Months)
This is the metric sophisticated investors use to compare deals — and it's built into the LendlyX DealScore.
The Costs Most People Forget
When calculating ROI, investors commonly miss:
- Loan extension fees — if you go past your original term
- Interest on the full loan — some lenders charge interest on undisbursed rehab funds
- Utility costs during rehab — $200–$500/month adds up
- Property taxes during hold — varies wildly by market
- Opportunity cost — capital locked in one deal can't work on another
- Unexpected rehab overruns — scope changes, hidden damage, material price increases
A Better Framework: Cash-on-Cash Return
Some investors prefer cash-on-cash return, which measures the actual cash profit against the actual cash deployed:
Cash-on-Cash = (Cash Profit ÷ Cash Deployed) × 100
This is particularly useful when comparing deals with different leverage ratios. A deal with 90% LTC looks different from one with 80% LTC, even if the underlying property economics are similar.
How to Use ROI in Deal Selection
Here's a simple decision framework:
- Target minimum annualized ROI: 40–60% for most markets
- Walk away if: Annualized ROI drops below 25% under stress-tested assumptions
- Stress test by: Adding 2 months to your timeline and 15% to your rehab budget
If the deal still hits your target after stress testing, it's probably worth pursuing.
The Bottom Line
ROI isn't just a number — it's a decision-making tool. But only if you calculate it correctly and compare deals on an annualized basis.
Stop using spreadsheets that miss half the costs. Run your next deal through the LendlyX DealScore and see the real numbers before you commit.
