Back to Blog

Deal Analysis

Underwriting Rehab Deals: What the Numbers Should Tell You

LendlyX Team6 min read

Good underwriting is not about running numbers — it is about knowing which numbers matter and what they reveal about a deal's true risk profile.

Underwriting Rehab Deals: What the Numbers Should Tell You

Numbers tell stories. Every fix-and-flip deal generates dozens of data points: purchase price, ARV, renovation budget, carrying costs, closing costs, projected profit. But underwriting is not about collecting numbers — it is about reading them. The best underwriters do not just calculate returns. They identify the assumptions hiding behind the calculations.

The Five Numbers That Matter Most

1. Loan-to-ARV Ratio (LTARV)

This ratio tells you how much of the property's projected after-repair value is covered by the loan. Most private lenders target an LTARV between 65% and 75%.

LTARV RangeRisk Assessment
Below 60%Conservative — significant equity cushion
60–70%Moderate — standard for experienced borrowers
70–75%Elevated — requires strong borrower track record
Above 75%High — typically requires additional collateral or guarantees

2. Renovation-to-Purchase Ratio

When renovation costs exceed 50% of the purchase price, the deal carries higher execution risk. The more work required, the more things can go wrong.

3. Holding Period Assumptions

Every month a project extends costs the investor in interest, insurance, taxes, and utilities. A deal that pencils at six months may not pencil at nine. Stress-test the holding period.

4. Comparable Sale Depth

How many quality comps support the ARV? Three strong comps within a half-mile are far better than six marginal comps scattered across different neighborhoods.

5. Contractor Bid Variance

If the lowest contractor bid is $80,000 and the highest is $140,000, the scope of work is not well-defined. High bid variance is a red flag for scope and cost risk.

"The numbers should make you feel either confident or cautious," says the LendlyX team. "If they make you feel confused, you do not have enough data yet."

How LendlyX Supports Better Underwriting

LendlyX's deal analysis tools help you evaluate these metrics systematically:

  • Multi-scenario modeling for best, base, and worst-case outcomes
  • Comp analysis tools with distance and recency filters
  • Renovation budget benchmarks based on property type and market
  • Holding cost calculators that stress-test different timelines
  • Portfolio-level metrics that reveal patterns across your deals

"Good underwriting is repeatable," the LendlyX team notes. "LendlyX makes it a process, not a judgment call."

The Bottom Line

The deal looks great on paper — but paper does not show you the risks hiding in the assumptions. Underwrite the assumptions, not just the numbers.

Ready to underwrite with confidence?Request a demo.

Share:LinkedInX
  1. 1People
  2. 2Evidence
  3. 3Property
  4. 4Decisions

About LendlyX

LendlyX is Lending Intelligence Infrastructure for private real estate lending. LendlyX verifies every identity, document, and inspection photo behind a loan before capital moves — replacing the spreadsheets, scattered emails, and manual review that put capital at risk. Founded in Dallas, TX, LendlyX serves private lenders, capital providers, and real estate borrowers nationwide.

Media Contact: media@lendlyx.com | www.lendlyx.com

Ready to streamline your workflow?

See how LendlyX helps borrowers and lenders work better together.